1. USA
  2. New York
  3. Fire Island
  4. Villa Rentals

Fire Island Villa Rentals & Homes

Find villas near Fire Island - We found 3 exact matches

About Fire Island Luxury Rental on Old Mansions

Old Mansions has more than 3 villas near Fire Island. These rentals have all the luxury accoutrements to give you comfort, including amenities such as - private swimming pools, WIFI, spas, hot tubs, and more.

Old Mansions has a wide range of villa rentals near Fire Island, and there are different options for families, friends, or even couples. These rentals come in unique styles or sizes that would definitely suit your needs.

Old Mansions offers expectational rental villas that are out of the ordinary and not found elsewhere, whether you are traveling on a beachfront, seaside, mountain, or any destination. Old Mansions is an all-in-one travel platform that matches you with the perfect rental villa in Fire Island for your dream vacation, including top travel locations in the USA & the Rest of the World. Many have private pools, luxury bedrooms, and even features like tennis courts, beach volleyball, spas, fitness clubs & more.

Old Mansions Villas are available for last-minute bookings and may include special offers for Airbnb, VRBO & Old Mansions-style villas. So find your last-minute getaway today with Old Mansions in Fire Island, and get ready to enjoy maximum comfort on your next holiday.

Frequently Asked Questions About Fire Island Villa Rentals

What are the top rated Villa Rentals in Fire Island?

There are a lot of options in Fire Island. If you plan on staying in the Fire Island area, consider making a reservation for a few nights at one of these properties as these have been rated the top Villa Rentals in Fire Island:

What is the rate per night for renting a villa near Fire Island?

At Old Mansions, the average rental fee for standard villas in Fire Island is $1,801 per night. Old Mansions has a large database of quality villas near Fire Island that are suitable for families, a romantic getaway, or a solo trip with single or multiple bedrooms.

Are there any rental villas in Fire Island that are suitable for families?

Most of our listed villas are suitable for families. The number of rooms varies, and you can check out the complete list of villas in Fire Island to find what works for you.

Do your rental villas in Fire Island have indoor swimming pools?

Based on the 2026 data from our Old Mansions site, there are more than 3 private swimming pools or villas with indoor pools in or near Fire Island.